Bad Review Contemplations

By | March 17, 2008 | 3 Comments

Ego surfing again – very bad habit of mine – and found this interesting rumination on bad reviews which mentions The Electric Church. An interesting quote:

2. Do you temper your feelings about books you didn’t like, so as not to completely slam them? Why or why not?

. . .I also temper them because sometimes I truly see reasons why others may like the book. For instance “The Electric Church” by Jeff Somers. I didn’t like his writing style, or the style/genre of the story. The writing style to me was annoying, but the story style may really appeal to some. I know it would, because I was one of the few that didn’t really like “Altered Carbon” by Richard Morgan. But in sci-fi circles, it is considered a great novel. And it is along some similar lines as “The Electric Church”.

Since I’m generally fascinated by bad reviews of my own work (which aren’t as rare as they should be, dagnabbit) I found this an interesting read. One important thing to remember, sometimes, is that reviewers are people and readers too, and they usually have very good reasons for not liking your work. You don’t have to agree with them, of course, but you should also remind yourself that you’re probably not half as smart and talented as you think you are. Or is that just me? Probably just me.

Categories:

3 Comments

  • Craig says:

    Even if you’re not half as smart and talented as you think you are, you’re still way smart and talented, right?

    And even if you’re not as smart and talented as I think you are, you’re not going to tell me, right?

  • jsomers says:

    I will claim to be a genius until my dying day, and possibly beyond it, no worries.

    J

  • Craig says:

    Whew! Had me worried for a minute…

loading